45. When Natural Consequences Don’t Work, Use Smart Discipline
We try not to use punishment or reward as ways to motivate our child’s actions because it diminishes their intrinsic motivation and harms the parent/child relationship. See my episode on how we use an evidence-based approach that utilizes natural consequences.
But there are times when natural consequences alone don’t work. Like if she refuses to get in the car and I say, “OK, well then we’re not going to the store.” She says, “Fine, I don’t wanna go to the store anyway.” And then what? I don’t want to yell, threaten, or bribe her, but I still need her to do the thing.
Enter, Smart Discipline. It quickly transformed those daily power struggles through a system that allows her to choose to comply and teach herself accountability from an early age. I teach you the basics in this episode, and there’s a link to the book at the bottom.
I also discuss the emotional side of discipline. Kids are still going to have feelings when they face consequences, and part of the job is holding space for those feelings while still maintaining the boundary.
In this episode, we explore:
Key Topics Discussed
• The Smart Discipline system for encouraging cooperation
• How house agreements create clear expectations for kids
• The X chart that lets children choose between compliance or a consequence
• Why discipline works better when kids feel ownership of the decision
• Supporting kids’ emotions while still enforcing boundaries
• Why calm delivery and consistency from parents matter
Resources Mentioned
Book: Smart Discipline: Fast, Lasting Solutions for Your Peace of Mind and Your Child's Self-Esteem
https://www.amazon.com/dp/0066212391?_encoding=UTF8&psc=1&ref_=cm_sw_r_cp_ud_dp_KMHF53J6SAFYXWHZN0KM
Get a copy of our Smart Discipline Chart System:
Watch: Why We Don’t Punish or Reward Our Daughter? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TAF35tAQxh4&list=PLV-0dTh77R_nI1i3WZ7kYeagM51WeC2-h
Watch: The Parenting Mistake That Makes Tantrums Worse https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I7dE_MOlwXk&list=PLV-0dTh77R_nI1i3WZ7kYeagM51WeC2-h&index=28
👉 Get 15% off your first Serenity Kids order with code: DADICATED15
Watch the Full Episode
Joe Carr is an entrepreneur, advocate, and passionate educator on fatherhood and partnership. Driven by a desire to provide high-quality, nutrient-dense baby food for his daughter Della, Joe and his wife founded Serenity Kids baby food brand after experiencing their own health transformations through clean eating. Now, alongside his work in revolutionizing baby nutrition, Joe is on a mission to help new dads navigate the transformational journey of fatherhood. Through his podcast and social media platform Dadicated Joe, he shares real, honest conversations about showing up for your children, supporting your partner, and embracing the identity shift that comes with becoming a dad.
👉 Get 15% off your first Serenity Kids order with code: DADICATED15 https://myserenitykids.com/
